torachan | Entries tagged with reading:fic

On my post the other day about encouragement,

nindulgence linked to a cool post of hers where she asked people on her flist if they wanted concrit.

Since I'm coming to the end of my reviewing project, but still want to review stuff I read, I figured I'd ask here, too.

When I say reviews, I mean me talking about what I liked and didn't. This is not necessarily constructive, as me saying I hate mpreg when you love it is not something that will improve your writing. Reviews are mainly for me and for other readers; their purpose is not to help the author improve their skills. Examples of reviews I've written can be found here.

Concrit, on the other hand is more me going through and pointing out things that need work on in a technical sense as well as pointing out things I thought worked particularly well. This is geared towards helping the writer. An example of concrit I've given can be found here.

If you choose yes, that does not mean I will do this for all your fics, or even that I will read all your fics. If I read and have the time and inclination to do more than just comment on the fic, however, I will keep the results of this poll in mind.

Anyone can feel free to take this poll, whether I have you friended or not.

[Poll #732612]

And in case you somehow missed it, concrit and reviews are always more than welcome on my own writing.

Also haaaaaa,

i_smile, I totally did not remember you gave me crit on

ccfp_ii. ^_^;; (Wow, was that really that long ago?)

Current Mood: hungry
Current Music: Good Charlotte - Time After Time

For

jedi__santa, I got Possession by

glasshouseslive (Qui/Obi; non-con fic that seems like the sort of thing a lot of the TPM fans on my flist would really enjoy)

For

slashababy, I got Corners and Rhythms by

jocondite (Dom/Lij, Dom/Orli, Orli/Lij; angsty, unhappy fic with no real resolution...mmm...love it)

For

yuletide, I got Someone Else on Top by

shanalle (Closer, snippets of Larry's POV throughout the events of the film)

For

harry_holidays, I got Practice Makes Perfect by

se_spotwood (Sirius/Remus, schmoopy schoolboy fic)

Profile

Page Summary

Concrit and reviews
Exchange fics

Active Entries

Journal Options

Tags

100 things [21]
100quills
- sirius/remus [1]
14valentines [16]
a light to get me there (wip) [1]
about me [24]
ace attorney [1]
andyverse (series) [6]
anonimity (wip) [3]
art [26]
art recs [7]
backstreet vamps (series) [2]
book club [3]
books [221]
- !2003 [5]
- !2006 [1]
- !2007 [17]
- !2008 [16]
- !2009 [64]
- !2010 [44]
- !2011 [19]
- !2012 [10]
- !2013 [3]
- !author of color [73]
- !comics [11]
- !japanese [15]
- !non-fiction [28]
- !queer author [37]
- !short stories [7]
- !young adult [63]
- abdel-fattah randa [1]
- alarcon daniel [1]
- alexie sherman [2]
- alvarez julia [2]
- amagi seimaru [3]
- anderson m.t. [1]
- atwood margaret [1]
- avasthi swati [1]
- baker james robert [1]
- baker kyle [2]
- balish chris [1]
- besson philippe [1]
- blume judy [1]
- brinkman kiara [1]
- brooks max [1]
- brown rachel manija [1]
- bruchac joseph [1]
- burt guy [1]
- cairo laney [1]
- cameron deborah [1]
- carriger gail [1]
- choi sook nyul [1]
- cisneros sandra [1]
- colbert stephen [1]
- collins suzanne [3]
- comeau joey [1]
- conan doyle arthur [1]
- coogan michael [1]
- cross shauna [1]
- danielewski mark z. [1]
- diaz junot [1]
- dully howard [1]
- duncker patricia [1]
- dunton-downer leslie [1]
- erdrich louise [1]
- evaristo bernardine [1]
- fforde jasper [1]
- fine cordelia [1]
- foer jonathan safran [1]
- fuller lois hamilton [1]
- gaiman neil [1]
- gates henry louis jr [1]
- ghosh amitav [1]
- gibbons dave [1]
- gidney craig laurance [1]
- goldberg myla [1]
- grant mira [1]
- greer andrew sean [1]
- hamasaki tatsuya [1]
- hidier tanuja desai [1]
- hornby nick [1]
- hudlin reginald [1]
- ishida ira [2]
- jacobs john hornor [1]
- johnson angela [1]
- july miranda [1]
- kadohata cynthia [1]
- kaneshiro kazuki [2]
- katcher brian [1]
- kay jackie [5]
- keller helen [1]
- king stephen [6]
- kirino natsuo [1]
- kizaki kaya [2]
- knight michael muhammad [1]
- kogawa joy [1]
- kusakabe masatoshi [1]
- lee jennifer 8 [1]
- lindqvist john ajvide [1]
- lloyd david [1]
- loewen james w. [1]
- love jeremy [1]
- maguire gregory [1]
- malkani gautam [1]
- martin s.i. [1]
- mccarthy cormac [1]
- mcewan ian [1]
- mcgruder aaron [1]
- meehan dawn [1]
- millington mil [1]
- mitsui hideki [1]
- mochizuki ken [1]
- moore alan [2]
- morales robert [1]
- mori kyoko [1]
- munoz jose esteban [1]
- murakami haruki [1]
- murakami ryu [1]
- mwangi meja [1]
- namioka lensey [2]
- newman sharan [1]
- niffenegger audrey [1]
- o'malley bryan lee [1]
- onda riku [1]
- oyeyemi helen [1]
- ozeki ruth [1]
- pahl jon [1]
- painter nell irvin [1]
- palahniuk chuck [3]
- peters julie anne [3]
- pilkington doris [1]
- pratchett terry [12]
- radosh daniel [1]
- rechy john [2]
- revoyr nina [1]
- robb graham [1]
- roberts dorothy [1]
- rosoff meg [1]
- rowling j.k. [5]
- samarasan preeta [1]
- sanchez alex [2]
- santiago esmeralda [1]
- sapphire [1]
- sayers joey alison [3]
- scholinski daphne [1]
- schulman sarah [4]
- selvadurai shyam [1]
- sherman martin [1]
- shiraiwa gen [1]
- shiverick mary [1]
- simner janni lee [1]
- smith ali [3]
- smith andrea [1]
- smith cynthia leitich [1]
- smith sherri l. [2]
- stryker susan [1]
- takami koushun [1]
- tamaki jillian [2]
- tamaki mariko [2]
- tan shaun [1]
- truss lynne [1]
- uchida yoshiko [1]
- van camp richard [1]
- weisberger lauren [1]
- whitehead colson [1]
- winton tim [1]
- wittlinger ellen [1]
- woo sung j. [1]
- woodson jacqueline [1]
- wright betty ren [1]
- yamanaka lois-ann [2]
- yep laurence [1]
- yoon carol kaesuk [1]
- zumas leni [1]
candy [52]
- australia/nz [13]
- austria [2]
- belgium [1]
- brazil [1]
- canada [3]
- finland [1]
- germany [2]
- indonesia [1]
- italy [1]
- japan [31]
- korea [1]
- turkey [1]
- uk [10]
- us [21]
- vietnam [1]
cars [1]
challenges [8]
charity auctions [6]
chiaroscuro (series) [18]
concerts [19]
confessions (wip) [7]
daily happiness [1507]
deadlines [1]
decluttering [35]
deliberate badfic [1]
disability [2]
eminence front (wip) [1]
ewan [18]
fallback crutch (abandoned) [2]
falling for the straight ones (wip) [2]
fanfic100
- dom/lij [14]
- jude/ewan [53]
- sirius [11]
fic [275]
fic offers [1]
fic
- !abandoned wips [9]
- !commentary [19]
- !remixes [13]
- a.i. [1]
- aoi hana [1]
- avatar [2]
- bakuman [1]
- big bang theory [1]
- bleach [3]
- brokeback mountain [1]
- challenges [12]
- closer [1]
- community [1]
- dark is rising [1]
- death note [1]
- digimon [2]
- dinosaur comics [1]
- enemy at the gates [2]
- hanazakari no kimitachi e [1]
- harry potter [25]
- hikaru no go [1]
- hot fuzz [1]
- huge [1]
- i heart huckabees [2]
- index [1]
- jude law/ewan mcgregor [85]
- k-on [1]
- kavalier and clay [1]
- kinki kids [1]
- leverage [2]
- liam neeson/jason isaacs [10]
- lotrips [20]
- mina de malfois [1]
- misc rpf [25]
- nana [2]
- one piece [1]
- penny arcade [1]
- peter pan [3]
- pirates of the caribbean [2]
- ppoi [1]
- psyren [1]
- recs [5]
- requests [4]
- sailor moon [1]
- sarah connor chronicles [1]
- scott pilgrim [1]
- seinfeld [1]
- shallow grave [3]
- sherlock holmes [1]
- sky captain [4]
- star wars [8]
- stargate atlantis [24]
- supernatural [2]
- ultra maniac [1]
- vampire chronicles [28]
- yotsuba&! [2]
films [65]
flocked posts [3]
follow friday [1]
food [50]
for a price (abandoned) [2]
fucking mice [7]
games [50]
gardening [1]
glitch [10]
graphics [3]
graze [9]
high cost of renting (wip) [3]
hit count meme [3]
homestuck [11]
icons [44]
japanese [2]
jude [4]
kaleidoscope [1]
kink bingo [9]
layouts [3]
lego lord of the rings [4]
links [193]
linkspam [35]
lists [20]
lyrics [10]
manga [272]
- !boys love [3]
- !josei [19]
- !seinen [37]
- !shoujo [50]
- !shounen [45]
- !summaries [22]
- !weekly jump [29]
- !yuri [4]
- abe shuuji [1]
- amagi seimaru [5]
- amano akira [3]
- arakawa hiromu [6]
- asada hiroyuki [3]
- asano inio [3]
- ashihara hinako [1]
- ayatsuji yukito [1]
- azuma kiyohiko [2]
- chiya toriko [3]
- fujisaki kou [1]
- fujita kazuhiro [1]
- furuya usamaru [2]
- hebizou [2]
- hoshino katsura [2]
- isayama hajime [1]
- itou junji [2]
- iwashiro toshiaki [7]
- kajio shinji [2]
- kakifly [1]
- kakizaki masasumi [1]
- kanari youzaburou [1]
- kaneshiro youzaburou [1]
- katsura hoshino [1]
- kawahara kazune [4]
- kishimoto masashi [10]
- kiyohara hiro [1]
- kon satoshi [1]
- kubo tite [6]
- kujira [1]
- kumota haruko [1]
- kurita riku [1]
- kusakawa nari [1]
- makimura satoru [1]
- mizusawa megumi [4]
- morimoto kozueko [1]
- morinaga milk [2]
- morita yuuko [1]
- mutou hiromu [1]
- nagata masami [1]
- nakahara aya [1]
- nakamura ching [1]
- nakamura yoshiki [1]
- nananan kiriko [1]
- nishioka kyoudai [2]
- obata takeshi [10]
- oda eiichirou [6]
- ogawa youko [1]
- oguri saori [5]
- okazaki kyouko [1]
- ooba tsugumi [10]
- rokuhana chiyo [3]
- sadamoto yoshiyuki [1]
- sahara mizu [1]
- sakaki kenji [1]
- satou fumiya [6]
- serizawa yukiko [1]
- shiina karuho [5]
- shimizu aki [1]
- shimura takako [8]
- shinkai makoto [1]
- shintani kaoru [1]
- shouji youko [1]
- suzuki yumiko [1]
- takahashi rumiko [2]
- takaya natsuki [1]
- takei hiroyuki [1]
- tamura yumi [23]
- tonogai yoshiki [1]
- toriyama akira [1]
- tsuda masami [1]
- tsuda mikiyo [1]
- tsuruta kenji [2]
- ueda miwa [1]
- umino chica [1]
- umino nagiko [2]
- urasawa naoki [1]
- watashiya kaworu [1]
- yagi norihiro [1]
- yamada nari [1]
- yamaji ebine [1]
- yamazaki takako [2]
- yazawa ai [1]
- yoshinaga fumi [2]
- yoshizumi wataru [3]
marnowrimo [3]
memes [212]
- writing [6]
meta [80]
monthly goals [9]
movies [3]
msts [11]
music [796]
- alphabetical favorites [23]
my summer abroad (wip) [1]
new super mario bros [3]
nostalgia [4]
original fiction [4]
phone posts [3]
photos [53]
picspam [2]
plot bunnies [66]
podfic [3]
porn logic [4]
queer [1]
race [3]
rants [73]
reading
- fic [2]
recs [259]
recs (2006) [1]
recs
- adventure time [1]
- american idol [1]
- anne of green gables [1]
- apartment 3-g [1]
- avatar the last airbender [4]
- avengers [1]
- baby-sitters club [3]
- bandom [7]
- batman [1]
- battlestar galactica [2]
- better off ted [1]
- brothers and sisters [1]
- calvin and hobbes [1]
- captain america [1]
- castle [1]
- code monkey [1]
- community [5]
- contact [1]
- discworld [3]
- due south [7]
- fall out boy [2]
- full house [1]
- glee [5]
- gravity falls [1]
- happy endings [1]
- hark! a vagrant [3]
- harry potter [72]
- high school musical [1]
- homestuck [5]
- hot fuzz [2]
- huge [3]
- if on a winter's night [1]
- inception [1]
- internet memes [1]
- invader zim [2]
- iron man [8]
- jude/ewan [10]
- kamikaze girls [1]
- katekyou hitman reborn [1]
- kavalier & clay [1]
- kimi ni todoke [1]
- leverage [3]
- lotrips [23]
- misc animanga [4]
- misc film [16]
- misc games [1]
- misc lit [15]
- misc music [2]
- misc rpf [8]
- misc tv [7]
- misc webcomics [3]
- mulan [1]
- music videos [1]
- mystery solving teens [1]
- nana [1]
- new girl [1]
- nobuta wo produce [1]
- oglaf [1]
- original fic [4]
- paradise kiss [1]
- parks and recreation [2]
- pinky and the brain [1]
- pirates of the caribbean [1]
- powerpuff girls [1]
- pundits [1]
- pushing daisies [1]
- sarah connor chronicles [1]
- scooby-doo [1]
- scott pilgrim [2]
- sherlock [3]
- sherlock holmes [28]
- sherlock holmes rpf [3]
- sky captain [1]
- son of a preacher man [1]
- star wars [5]
- stargate atlantis [72]
- stargate sg-1 [2]
- supernatural [18]
- the beatles [1]
- the big bang theory [2]
- the middleman [2]
- the simpsons [4]
- the west wing [1]
- the wizard of oz [1]
- ugly betty [3]
- whip it [2]
- winnie the pooh [1]
- x-files [2]
- x-men [1]
remix [1]
requests [1]
reviews [315]
- 20th century boys [1]
- ace attorney [1]
- american idol [2]
- anne of green gables [1]
- apartment 3-g [1]
- avatar the last airbender [3]
- avengers [1]
- baby-sitters club [3]
- bandom [14]
- batman [1]
- battlestar galactica [2]
- better off ted [1]
- brothers and sisters [1]
- calvin and hobbes [2]
- captain america [1]
- castle [1]
- chronicles of narnia [1]
- claymore [1]
- code monkey [1]
- commercials [1]
- community [6]
- contact [1]
- degrassi [1]
- digimon [1]
- discworld [4]
- dr horrible [1]
- dracula [1]
- due south [11]
- fall out boy [2]
- full house [1]
- futurama [1]
- glee [7]
- gravity falls [1]
- happy endings [1]
- hark! a vagrant [3]
- harry potter [113]
- high school musical [1]
- hikaru no go [2]
- homestuck [2]
- hot fuzz [2]
- huge [4]
- husbands [1]
- hyperbole and a half [1]
- if on a winter's night [1]
- inception [2]
- internet memes [1]
- invader zim [2]
- iron man [11]
- johnny's entertainment [2]
- jude/ewan [9]
- kamikaze girls [1]
- katekyou hitman reborn [1]
- kavalier & clay [1]
- kimi ni todoke [1]
- let the right one in [1]
- leverage [4]
- lotrips [29]
- misc animanga [14]
- misc comics [1]
- misc film [23]
- misc games [5]
- misc lit [25]
- misc music [3]
- misc rpf [18]
- misc tv [16]
- misc webcomics [3]
- mulan [1]
- music videos [1]
- mystery solving teens [1]
- nana [1]
- new girl [1]
- nobuta wo produce [2]
- oglaf [2]
- original fic [6]
- paradise kiss [1]
- paranorman [1]
- parks and recreation [5]
- peter pan [1]
- pinky and the brain [1]
- pirates of the caribbean [3]
- pokemon [1]
- popslash [4]
- powerpuf girls [1]
- pundits [2]
- pushing daisies [1]
- sarah connor chronicles [1]
- scooby-doo [1]
- scott pilgrim [3]
- sherlock [3]
- sherlock holmes [28]
- sherlock holmes rpf [5]
- skating rpf [1]
- sky captain [1]
- smallville [5]
- so you think you can dance [1]
- son of a preacher man [1]
- spaced [1]
- star wars [11]
- star wars rpf [1]
- stargate atlantis [100]
- stargate sg-1 [2]
- supernatural [29]
- supernatural rpf [1]
- the beatles [1]
- the big bang theory [2]
- the middleman [2]
- the simpsons [4]
- the west wing [1]
- the wizard of oz [1]
- ugly betty [4]
- whip it [2]
- wilby wonderful [1]
- winnie the pooh [1]
- x-files [2]
- x-men [4]
- yotsuba&! [1]
sales [29]
scanlations [68]
stupid [17]
super mario galaxy [7]
super mario world [1]
sweet charity [2]
this pastime (wip) [9]
three weeks for dreamwidth [48]
trans [25]
transfic mini fest [20]
tv [267]
- adventure time [4]
- andy richter controls the universe [2]
- arrested development [1]
- avatar [10]
- being erica [1]
- better off ted [2]
- big bang theory [7]
- brothers & sisters [3]
- call the midwife [1]
- community [12]
- degrassi [2]
- dr. horrible [3]
- elementary [1]
- flight of the conchords [1]
- glee [3]
- goodness gracious me [1]
- gravity falls [1]
- happy endings [1]
- hourou musuko [1]
- huge [2]
- leverage [6]
- life on mars [1]
- lost girl [2]
- mama wa mukashi papa datta [1]
- modern family [8]
- mumbai calling [1]
- my little pony [4]
- my mad fat diary [1]
- mythbusters [2]
- new girl [1]
- nihonjin no shiranai nihongo [1]
- no heroics [1]
- nobuta. wo produce [4]
- outsourced [2]
- parks and recreation [11]
- psych [3]
- puella magi madoka magica [1]
- pushing daisies [12]
- queer as folk [1]
- running wilde [2]
- sarah connor chronicles [2]
- sherlock [2]
- some girls [1]
- stargate atlantis [64]
- state of georgia [1]
- supernatural [70]
- taisho yakyuu musume [1]
- the fosters [1]
- the middleman [1]
- the mindy project [2]
- the simpsons [1]
- ugly betty [41]
- venture bros [1]
- wonderfalls [1]
using words (wip) [22]
videos [2]
vids [1]
walks [3]
warnings [1]
wednesday reading [23]
what is this i don't even [2]
wishlist [1]
writing [118]
writing progress [75]
wtf27 [1]
year in review [3]
yuletide [20]

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags